The article examines the substantive content of the quality criteria applicable to decisions made by an investigating judge concerning the revocation or modification of preventive measures, namely legality, reasoned justification, and fairness. The empirical basis of the study comprises a qualitative analysis of more than 200 rulings issued by courts in various regions of the Republic in 2025–2026, as well as official statistics of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan for 2022–2026. The study reveals the widespread use of “template decisions” in national judicial practice, a more than twofold increase in the proportion of motions denied following the introduction of the institution of the investigating judge (from 2.3% to 5.1%), and disparities of up to thirteenfold across regions. The article proposes specifying the content of the fairness criterion through a three-stage proportionality test and an individualization requirement. The study concludes by substantiating three proposals aimed at establishing mandatory substantive requirements for investigating judges’ rulings.
| Mualliflar | Omonov, Zafarjon, Омонов, Зафаржон, Омонов, Зафаржон |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations |
| Nashriyot | In Science МЧЖ |
| ISSN | 2181-1415 |
| Nashr sanasi | 2026-08-25 |
| Jild | 7 |
| Son | 4 |
| Betlar | 261-268 |
| Til | Ingliz |
| Ilmiy soha | Yuridik |
| DOI | 10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268 |
| Indeksga qo‘shilgan | 2026-09-09 |
DOI: 10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268 · Maqolaning asl sahifasi
тергов судьяси, қонунийлик, асослилик, адолатлилик, мутаносиблик, шаблон қарорлар, негатив мотивлаш мажбурияти, индивидуаллаштириш, следственный судья, законность, обоснованность, справедливость, пропорциональность, шаблонные решения, обязанность негативной мотивировки, индивидуализация, investigative judge, legality, validity, fairness, proportionality, template decisions, duty to provide reasons for refusal, individualization
| APA | Omonov, Zafarjon, Омонов, Зафаржон, & Омонов, Зафаржон (2026). Criteria of Legality, Validity, and Fairness of Investigative Judges’ Decisions: A Theoretical Analysis and Assessment Based on Judicial Practice. Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations, 7(4), 261-268. https://doi.org/10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268 |
|---|---|
| GOST (OAK) | Omonov, Zafarjon, Омонов, Зафаржон, Омонов, Зафаржон Criteria of Legality, Validity, and Fairness of Investigative Judges’ Decisions: A Theoretical Analysis and Assessment Based on Judicial Practice // Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations. – 2026. – T. 7, № 4. – P. 261-268. – DOI: 10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268. |
| MLA | Omonov, Zafarjon, Омонов, Зафаржон, and Омонов, Зафаржон. “Criteria of Legality, Validity, and Fairness of Investigative Judges’ Decisions: A Theoretical Analysis and Assessment Based on Judicial Practice.” Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations, 7(4), 261-268, 2026. https://doi.org/10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268 |
| Chicago | Omonov, Zafarjon, Омонов, Зафаржон, and Омонов, Зафаржон. “Criteria of Legality, Validity, and Fairness of Investigative Judges’ Decisions: A Theoretical Analysis and Assessment Based on Judicial Practice.” Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations, 7(4), 261-268 (2026). https://doi.org/10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268 |
| Harvard | Omonov, Zafarjon, Омонов, Зафаржон, and Омонов, Зафаржон (2026) ‘Criteria of Legality, Validity, and Fairness of Investigative Judges’ Decisions: A Theoretical Analysis and Assessment Based on Judicial Practice’, Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations, 7(4), 261-268. https://doi.org/10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268 |
| BibTeX | @article{omonovzafarjon2026,
title = {Criteria of Legality, Validity, and Fairness of Investigative Judges’ Decisions: A Theoretical Analysis and Assessment Based on Judicial Practice},
author = {Omonov, Zafarjon and Омонов, Зафаржон and Омонов, Зафаржон},
journal = {Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations},
year = {2026},
volume = {7},
number = {4},
pages = {261-268},
doi = {10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268},
url = {https://doi.org/10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss4-pp261-268}
} |
Boshqa maqola uchun iqtibos tayyorlash
Based on historical archival and hydrological-statistical data, this article analyzes the largest engineering transformation that occurred in the 1970s and 1980s in the irrigation system of the lower reaches of the Amu…
This article provides a scholarly analysis of the role and significance of cooperation among internal affairs bodies, educational institutions, inspector-psychologists, and interaction based on the…
В статье с теоретико-правовых позиций анализируется институт предварительного (концептуального) публичного обсуждения — размещения на портале обсуждения проектов нормативно-правовых актов вопроса о целесообразности…
A gap between declarative knowledge of pedagogical practice and the ability to implement it was identified using metacognitive pedagogy as an example. A four-component model for preparing future educators was developed…
This article analyzes the protection of investor rights in Islamic finance under the existing legal framework of Uzbekistan. The institutions of Islamic banking, Islamic financial transactions, and investment deposits…
The article compares the models of civil liability for breach of construction contracts in developed jurisdictions. It demonstrates that the general concept encompasses mechanisms of different legal nature: fault-based…
Based on Recommendation Rec(2001)10 of the Council of Europe, The European Code of Police Ethics, the article analyzes the importance of legality, professional ethics, personal responsibility, compliance with lawful…
This article examines the legal status of internal affairs bodies based on an analysis of the substance and significance of the methodological, organizational, and legal foundations underlying the reforms being…
The article presents an organizational and managerial model for developing the creative potential of principals of specialized and creativity schools. The model is based on the consistent interconnection of…
This article examines the theoretical foundations of English writing competence among law students and analyzes its linguodidactic characteristics in the context of professional foreign language education. The study…
Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations — barcha maqolalar · 2026-yil arxivi
In this article, the concept and types of the “object of crime” were studied and analyzed, in particular, the concepts of “general object”, “special object”, “direct object” and “generic object”, the legal…
This article analyses the role and significance of the institution of the investigating judge in the law of criminal procedure. This new institution, introduced as part of the judicial and legal reforms in Uzbekistan…
The article analyzes the concept of «offender», the difference between the concepts of «subject of the crime»? from the criminological concept of «person who committed a crime», the concept of «guilty», «the convict»…
This paper examines the specific features of using information and telecommunication technologies (ITT) for the illicit trafficking of prohibited items and substances. It notes that the development of anonymous…
This article examines the legal mechanisms for protecting the rights and legitimate interests of persons affected by domestic (family) violence. It analyzes the legislation of the Republic of Uzbekistan aimed at…
The article analyzes the role and importance of digitalization of the higher education system in preventing corruption. In particular, the importance of new information technologies introduced into the higher education…
This article examines the historical and legal evolution of international legal regulation and international cooperation of States in combating the illicit trafficking of narcotic drugs. It analyses the principal stages…
In the realm of information security, artificial intelligence is utilized not only for real-time operations, attack prediction, threat prevention, and the automation of authentication processes but also serves as a…
The international legal regulation of artificial intelligence at the global level is currently one of the key issues being addressed within the United Nations. The UN International Law Commission and the UN global…