This article examines the contradictions arising from the integration of artificial intelligence technologies into criminal justice systems and explores the conditions under which an optimal balance can be achieved between technological efficiency and fair trial guarantees. Drawing on a systematic review of current scholarly literature and a comparative analysis of legal systems across multiple jurisdictions, the authors identify and assess three competing research paradigms: technological optimism, critical algorithm studies, and the normative-oriented approach to legal artificial intelligence. The article identifies four significant gaps in the existing body of research: the geographic and institutional limitations of current scholarship, which largely neglects post-Soviet and Asian legal systems; the absence of comprehensive analysis of the cumulative impact of multiple algorithmic interventions on criminal defendants; the disconnect between normative legal analysis and empirical investigation; and the insufficient development of concrete institutional mechanisms for governing algorithmic systems in justice settings. The authors examine in detail how algorithmic opacity (the "black box" phenomenon), systematic errors, and structural bias threaten core procedural principles, including the presumption of innocence, the right to a defence, adversarial proceedings, and the individualisation of punishment. Particular attention is given to the specific features of post-Soviet legal systems, including that of Uzbekistan, which are characterised by a strong prosecutorial supervisory role — a feature that may serve both as a potential mechanism for controlling AI application and as a source of particular vulnerabilities. The study aims to develop an analytical framework for evaluating algorithmic systems used in criminal proceedings, grounded in the requirements of international human rights law and procedural legislation. The findings are intended to guide legislators and law enforcement practitioners in developing balanced regulatory approaches to artificial intelligence in the field of criminal justice.
| Mualliflar | Mukhitdinov, Fakhritdin, Mukhitdinov, Jakhongir, Мухитдинов, Фахритдин, Мухитдинов, Жахонгир, Muxitdinov, Faxritdin, Muxitdinov, Jahongir |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations |
| Nashr sanasi | 2026-06-05 |
| Jild | 7 |
| Son | 3 |
| Betlar | 13-43 |
| Til | Rus |
| DOI | 10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss3-pp13-43 |
DOI: 10.47689/2181-1415-vol7-iss3-pp13-43 · Maqolaning asl sahifasi
искусственный интеллект в уголовном правосудии, алгоритмическое принятие решений, справедливое судебное разбирательство, алгоритмическая предвзятость, «чёрный ящик», предиктивное правосудие, оценка риска рецидива, право на защиту, прозрачность алгоритмов, цифровизация правосудия, постсоветские правовые системы, уголовный процесс Узбекистана, artificial intelligence in criminal justice, algorithmic decision-making, fair trial guarantees, algorithmic bias, black box problem, predictive justice, recidivism risk assessment, right to defence, algorithmic transparency, digitalisation of justice, post-Soviet legal systems, criminal procedure in Uzbekistan, jinoiy odil sudlovda sun’iy intellekt, algoritmik qarorlar qabul qilish, adolatli sud muhokamasi, algoritmik noxolislik, "qora quti", prediktiv odil sudlov, retsidiv xavfini baholash, himoyalanish huquqi, algoritmlar shaffofligi, odil sudlovni raqamlashtirish, postsovet huquqiy tizimlari, O‘zbekiston jinoyat protsessi
This article analyzes the role of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) in ensuring peace and stability in Afghanistan. It examines the historical evolution of SCO–Afghanistan relations from 2001 to the present…
The article examines the institutional mechanisms of legal compliance and protection of entrepreneurship in Uzbekistan in the context of modernization of public administration and the development of a market economy…
This article analyzes theoretical and practical issues of protecting attorney-client privilege in the context of the digital transformation of society.
The article examines jurisdictional conflicts arising in the cross-border collection of digital evidence stored or processed within cloud infrastructure. The relevance of the topic is determined by the fact that…
This article analyzes the content and essence of supported employment services in ensuring the employment of persons with disabilities. It argues that supported employment services, unlike ordinary job placement…
The article provides a comparative legal analysis of the use of electronic data in criminal proceedings, taking into account international standards, as well as the experience of the United States, Canada, the European…
This study analyzes the theoretical and practical aspects of using innovative teaching methods in organizing biology lessons in general secondary schools from a scientific and pedagogical perspective. In the course of…
The article examines theoretical, legal, and applied problems related to the use of electronic data storage media and digital evidence in criminal proceedings. The relevance of the topic is determined by the fact that…
This article examines the concepts of “minor” and “children in need of special protection and support from the state and society.” It analyzes current regulatory legal acts that safeguard the rights and legitimate…
The article examines issues of state regulation of investment activity. It identifies the goals and objectives that state regulation should address, analyzes investment legislation and the experience of its application…
Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations — barcha maqolalar