The article is devoted to a comparative legal analysis of causation in the criminal law of Germany and Uzbekistan as a category connecting an act with the resulting consequence in offences with a material corpus delicti. The purpose of the study is to identify similarities and differences in the theoretical foundations for establishing causation, legal regulation, judicial practice and evidentiary problems, as well as to formulate recommendations for improving the quality of law enforcement. Methodologically, the research is based on functional-comparative and dogmatic approaches and draws on primary sources (the StGB/StPO and the practice of the Bundesgerichtshof; the Criminal Code and Criminal Procedure Code of Uzbekistan and acts of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan), as well as modern scholarly publications in Russian and German over the last three decades. The article shows that the German model combines the broad factual test of conditio sine qua non (Bedingungstheorie) with subsequent normative filtering through objective attribution (objektive Zurechnung), whereas in Uzbekistan causation is both a mandatory subject of proof under the Criminal Procedure Code and is specified through Plenum explanations and official reviews of judicial practice.
| Mualliflar | Алиев Бобур Шерзодович |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Юриспруденция |
| Nashr sanasi | 2026-07-22 |
| Jild | 7 |
| Son | 2 |
| Til | Rus |
причинно-следственная связь; уголовное право; доказательство; conditio sine qua non (Bedingungstheorie); объективное вменение (objektive Zurechnung); адекватная причинность (adäquate Kausalität); множественность причин; альтернативная причинность; экспертиза; судебная практика; Германия; Узбекистан, causal link; criminal law; proof; conditio sine qua non (Bedingungstheorie); objective attribution (objektive Zurechnung); adequate causation (adäquate Kausalität); plurality of causes; alternative causation; expert examination; judicial practice; Germany; Uzbekistan., sabab-oqibat bogʻlanishi; jinoyat huquqi; isbotlash; conditio sine qua non (Bedingungstheorie); obyektiv vmeneniye (objektive Zurechnung); adekvat sababiylik (adäquate Kausalität); sabablar koʻpligi; alternativ sababiylik; ekspertiza; sud amaliyoti; Germaniya; Oʻzbekiston
This article examines mechanisms for protecting corporate rights in the context of digital asset circulation in the Republic of Uzbekistan, drawing on national and international legal doctrine. The author analyzes the…
This article explores the development trends of the mediation institution in the Republic of Uzbekistan, examining its legal and practical aspects. The study analyzes the role of mediation in economic relations, the…
Organized crime is a constantly evolving phenomenon affecting all countries without exception. Organized criminal groups consist of three or more individuals, have a certain level of structure, and exist for a period of…
This article examines the extent to which the legislation of the Republic of Uzbekistan on mediation conforms to international standards applicable to labor relations. Through comparative legal analysis of ILO…
This article analyzes the concept of "plea bargaining," which is a modern institution of procedural economy and the rapid administration of justice in criminal proceedings, as well as its role and significance in…
This article examines the problems of legal regulation of the liability of digital platforms for violations of consumer rights in e-commerce in the Republic of Uzbekistan. Although the current legislation has already…
The institution of quasi-subjects in civil law represents one of the most dynamically developing legal categories, reflecting the law's continuous adaptation to changing socio-economic conditions. For centuries…
This article presents a comparative legal analysis of mediation in labor dispute resolution across Uzbekistan, the USA, Turkey, and the UAE. The methodology integrates comparative legal analysis, formal-legal…
The relevance of this topic is determined by the fact that majority shareholders play a decisive role in corporate governance. In this regard, the establishment of fiduciary duties for majority shareholders could…
The article examines theoretical and applied problems of antitrust qualification of anticompetitive agreements arising under conditions of algorithmic pricing. The author analyses the principal typologies of algorithmic…