On the erroneous interpretation of the origin and time of the appearance of the catacomb type of burial in the bronze age in central Asia

Ахмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов

Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past · 2021-yil

Annotatsiya

This article examines the origin of ancient catacomb-type graves, about its erroneous use at one time in relation to the graves of the Zamanbaba culture based on the historiography of Soviet archeology. At one time, V.A. Gorodtsov also mistakenly called the undercut graves catacomb, as evidenced by his graphic drawings. Our further studies of real catacomb graves on the territory of the Akhangaron Valley showed what a catacomb-type grave is, its internal structure and the time of its appearance in Central Asia. Unfortunately, Russian colleagues-archaeologists, without delving into the internal structure of catacomb-type graves, repeat the terminological errors of Soviet historiography, as evidenced by the candidate dissertation of Yu.G. Kutimova “The origin and ways of spreading the catacomb burial rite in Central Asia (based on the materials of the burial grounds of the Bronze Age) to which the authors' self-critical approach to determining the time of the appearance of the catacomb device of graves is devoted, also criticizes Russian colleagues in the interpretation and interpretation of archaeological sources of Central Asia in the Soviet conservatism historiography.

Maqola ma’lumotlari
MualliflarАхмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов
JurnalЎтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past
NashriyotЎзбекистон Миллий университети
ISSN2181-9599
Nashr sanasi2021-10-19
Jild4
Son10
TilIngliz
Ilmiy sohaTarix
Indeksga qo‘shilgan2026-08-27

Maqolaning asl sahifasi

Kalit so‘zlar

Заманбаба, Сапаллинская культура, В.А.Городцов, диссертация Ю.Г.Кутимова, Дулана Булак, Тайпан, Эрташ Дулана, Кавардан, Миграция, Сарматы, Прохоровская культура, Тиллатепа, Ранний Тулхар, Каунчинская культура, Zamanbaba, Sapalli culture, V.A. Gorodtsov, dissertation of Yu.G. Kutimov, Dulana Bulak, Taipan, Ertash Dulana, Kavardan, Migration, Sarmatians, Prokhorovka culture, Tillatepa, Early Tulkhar, Kaunchi culture, Замонбобо, Сополли маданияти, В.А.Городцов, Ю.Г.Кутимов диссертацияси, Дўлана Булоқ, Тайпан, Эртош Дўлана, Кавардан, Миграция, Сарматлар, Прохоров маданияти, Тиллатепа, Илк Тулхар, Қовунчи маданияти

Ilmiy soha

Tarix

Iqtibos keltirish

APAАхмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, & Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов (2021). ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA. Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past, 4(10). https://tadqiqot.uz/index.php/history/article/view/3036
GOST (OAK)Ахмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA // Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past. – 2021. – T. 4, № 10.
MLAАхмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, and Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов. “ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA.” Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past, 4(10), 2021. https://tadqiqot.uz/index.php/history/article/view/3036
ChicagoАхмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, and Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов. “ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA.” Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past, 4(10) (2021). https://tadqiqot.uz/index.php/history/article/view/3036
HarvardАхмадали Аскаров, Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков, and Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов (2021) ‘ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA’, Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past, 4(10). https://tadqiqot.uz/index.php/history/article/view/3036
BibTeX
@article{article2021,
  title = {ON THE ERRONEOUS INTERPRETATION OF THE ORIGIN AND TIME OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CATACOMB TYPE OF BURIAL IN THE BRONZE AGE IN CENTRAL ASIA},
  author = {Ахмадали Аскаров and Бехзод Имамали угли Исабеков and Убайдулла Мамат угли Исмойилов},
  journal = {Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past},
  year = {2021},
  volume = {4},
  number = {10},
  url = {https://tadqiqot.uz/index.php/history/article/view/3036}
}

Boshqa maqola uchun iqtibos tayyorlash

Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past jurnalidan boshqa maqolalar

Ўтмишга назар журнали / Журнал взгляд в прошлое /Journal of Look to the Past — barcha maqolalar · 2021-yil arxivi

Tarix sohasidagi boshqa maqolalar

Tarix sohasidagi OAK jurnallari