With this article, the author continues the cycle of his scientific publications dedicated to the study of the structure of criminal procedural evidence. Based on the arguments presented, the author comes to the conclusion that it is necessary to partially revise his previous position, which implies the consideration of the categories of “collecting evidence” and “forming evidence” as two autonomous ways of carrying out the first stage of proof. Instead, the author proposes to attach a somewhat conditional meaning to the category of “collection of evidence”, understanding by it any forms of behavior of participants in criminal proceedings aimed at obtaining and subsequent proceduralization of useful information. SUMMARY In this article, the author continues the series of scientific publications devoted to the study of the problems of collecting evidence as a cumulative stage of the work of the preliminary investigation bodies and the court with evidentiary materials in a criminal case. Moreover, these issues are considered in the context of a comparative analysis of the criminal procedure legislation of two sovereign states that emerged in the post Soviet space – Russia and Uzbekistan. In the first half of the article, the author introduces potential readers to his previous scientific positions on the essence of collecting evidence in criminal proceedings. And in the second part of the article, we consider the reasons that prompted a partial revision and rethinking of their previous positions. Based on these arguments, the author suggests that in the future the category "evidence collection" should be given a somewhat conditional meaning and that it should be understood as any form of behavior of participants in criminal proceedings aimed at obtaining and subsequent processing of useful information. The author believes that collection of evidence may be carried out through the implementation of two autonomous procedural mechanisms: a) formation of evidence, involving the creation (as the birth) of new educational resources through the procedural forms, i.e. through production in accordance with the CPC proceedings, consists in the perception of (study) the inquirer, investigator, court, as well as expert useful information and its transformation, transformation to the appropriate readings, expert opinions and results (protocols) of non-verbal investigative and judicial actions (and for the Uzbek criminal process-also audio, video and film recording materials that are Autonomous means of proof); b) attaching evidence to the materials of a criminal case that involves obtaining by presenting, requesting or withdrawing various items and documents, as well as their subsequent recognition as material evidence, other documents, expert opinions, results of operational search activities and administrative activities on the basis of a special state authority act of the body of inquiry, preliminary investigation or court, which gives them legal force and determines whether they can be used to justify law enforcement decisions.
| Mualliflar | Rossinskiy, Sergey, Россинский, Сергей, Россинский, Сергей |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations |
| Nashr sanasi | 2020-09-25 |
| Jild | 1 |
| Son | 1 |
| Betlar | 177-188 |
| Til | Rus |
| DOI | 10.47689/2181-1415-vol1-iss1-pp177-188 |
DOI: 10.47689/2181-1415-vol1-iss1-pp177-188 · Maqolaning asl sahifasi
Доказывание, Приобщение доказательств, Работа с доказательствами, Структура доказывания, Формирование доказательств, Proving, Attachment of evidence, Working with evidence, Evidence structure, Formation of evidence, доказывание; приобщение доказательств; работа с доказательствами; структура доказывания; формирование доказательств
The article analyzes tasks of simplified proceedings. The forms of simplified proceedings are considered as "summary proceedings" (England), "plea bargaining" (USA), "conditional refusal to initiate criminal…
Current epidemiological situation in morbidity and mortality in the world is characterized in the article, main social and economic indicators supporting spread of infectious agents are presented, principles, concepts…
The article analyzes the present state of the Institutionof advocacy in the Republic of Uzbekistan. It provides an investigation of existing problems, without which it is impossible to further reform the advocacy. The…
The article deals with functioning of financial market as an effective mechanism for accumulation and redistribution of financial resources on competitive basis between countries, regions, and industries. The analysis…
The article is devoted to improving legal policy implemented by the state in the Republic of Uzbekistan taking into account the peculiarities of introduction and development of information and communication technologies…
The article analyzes the impact of COVID-19 pandemic on employment and income of population. State anti-crisis policy is considered on the example of the Republic of Uzbekistan, which provides for macroeconomic and…
This article analyzes the determinants of crimes in the field of information technology and security. Based on the study of foreign experience and scientific and theoretical views, the causes and conditions of…
The article analyzes the role of the principle of the closest connection principle in the regulation of relations of international private law character, the nature of this principle as both a collision principle and a…
This article is devoted to the analysis of problems of banking legislation, regulation of banking services. Based on the study of foreign experience and scientific and theoretical views, ways to improve legislation in…
The article deals with the relevance of human biometric parameters almost in all spheres of social life. Human biometrics is used in the notary, banking and control management access systems. The biometric identifiers…
Жамият ва инновациялар / Общество и инновации / Society and innovations — barcha maqolalar