This article provides a comprehensive analysis of the procedural nature of a forensic expert’s opinion as evidence in criminal proceedings, the criteria for its assessment, and the theoretical and legal issues arising in law enforcement practice. The study examines the scientific validity, reliability, admissibility, and consistency of an expert opinion with other evidence as key factors determining its significance in the process of proof. The author substantiates that the current criminal procedural legislation does not sufficiently establish a special and differentiated procedure for assessing expert opinions, which leads to divergent approaches in law enforcement practice. The article considers compliance with procedural requirements, determination of the expert’s competence and impartiality, authenticity of the objects of examination and comparative samples, scientific reliability of the applied methodologies, logical consistency, and clarity of the opinion as separate assessment criteria. In addition, the necessity of developing a unified regulatory and methodological approach to the assessment of opinions issued by both state and non-state forensic expert institutions is substantiated. The conclusion notes that the implementation of the proposed criteria in practice will contribute to improving the effectiveness of evidence assessment, preventing procedural errors, and ensuring the quality of justice. The findings of the study are significant in terms of strengthening procedural guarantees for the use of special knowledge in criminal cases, ensuring an objective assessment of the evidentiary value of expert opinions, and establishing unified standards in judicial and investigative practice.
| Mualliflar | KUDRATOV , Sanjar |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Юрист ахборотномаси |
| Nashr sanasi | 2026-06-30 |
| Jild | 1 |
| Son | 3 |
| Betlar | 140-147 |
| Til | O‘zbek |
sud ekspertizasi, davlat va nodavlat sud eksperti, ekspert xulosasi, dalillar, jinoyat protsessi, baholash mezonlari, protsessual talablar, ilmiy asoslanganlik, xolislik, ishonchlilik.
This article analyzes the problems of transboundary environmental impacts in the Central Asian region and the issues of their international legal regulation. As sources of transboundary ecological risks in the region…
This article comprehensively examines the theoretical and legal foundations of the institution of circumstances precluding criminal proceedings, its place within the criminal justice system, and its significance in…
This article provides a comprehensive conceptual and legal analysis of the formation and evolution of the notion of transboundary impact in international law. The study examines the theoretical foundations of…
The article analyzes the legal framework and issues related to improving cooperation between investigative units of internal affairs bodies and citizens' self-government bodies. It highlights the role of mahalla…
This article analyzes the issues of implementing the principles of “Digital Assets and Private Law” developed by UNIDROIT into national legislation from a scientific and legal perspective. The purpose of this article is…
The article examines the “broken windows” theory as one of the significant criminological concepts of crime prevention. The approach developed by J. Wilson and G. Kelling is based on the assumption that indifference to…
This article examines contemporary theoretical, legal, and international legal aspects of corruption risks in the field of the protection and promotion of human rights. The relevance of the study is determined by the…
This article investigates the theoretical and scientific foundations, essence, and systematization of the prosecutor's legal means. The author conducts a comparative analysis of approaches by national and foreign…
This scientific article analyzes the mechanisms for preventing corruption risks in the activities of legal services within state bodies and organizations based on a comprehensive and systemic approach. The article…
This article presents a comparative legal analysis of consumer complaint mechanisms against e-commerce platform operators in the People's Republic of China and the Republic of Uzbekistan. The study is prompted by the…