This article analyzes the status and importance of the court as one of the subjects of proof in a criminal case. Foreign experience, a review of the legislation and the opinion of scientists on this issue are also analyzed. In particular, neither the legislator organs nor the representatives of the scientific community have a common point of view on the issue whether the court is the subject of proof or not, and if yes, what task it should perform in the process of proof. Even the international experience on this issue is different, in particular, among the CIS member countries, only under the legislation of Kazakhstan, the courts are deprived of the status of a subject of proof, while in Kyrgyzstan, the Russian Federation, Belarus present the contrary. There are positive and negative aspects of the status of the court as a subject of proof. In particular, depriving the court of the status of the subject of proof and leaving it exclusively in the status of an arbitrator or observer does not allow determining the truth in the case. Especially when the parties take a passive position in the performance of their tasks, there is a high probability of limiting the right of a person to justice. Based on the analysis, substantiated proposals are presented to determine the status of the court in the process of proving and improving legislation.
| Mualliflar | Mavlon Gafurov |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Одил судлов (электрон журнал) |
| Nashr sanasi | 2022-05-11 |
| Jild | 2 |
| Son | 2-3 |
| Betlar | 69-78 |
| Til | en |
| DOI | 10.51788/tsul.ccj.2.2-3./fcwi5442 |
DOI: 10.51788/tsul.ccj.2.2-3./fcwi5442 · Maqolaning asl sahifasi · PDF
The article examines the formation of the concept of latent crimes, studies the types and classification of latent crimes. In addition, the views and opinions of various scientists on the latent crime classification…
This article analyzes the concept of theft of other people’s property. Analyzing the views of researchers on the concept and signs of theft, suggestions and recommendations for improving the concept are provided…
This article discusses the procedural problems associated with the refusal or termination of proceedings in the case and aspects of the legal regulation of these issues when releasing a person from responsibility in…
This article devoted to elaborating the main principle of Criminal Law – the principle’s role in relation with inchoate crime. Author illuminates the principle of sentencing, their types – general and special, their…
The article deals with crimes against public morality in foreign legislation. Particular attention is paid to crimes related to prostitution, trafficking in pornographic products, destruction and damage to historical…
This article analyzes the activities of offence prevention, coordination of their activities, the role of law enforcement agencies in this area, early prevention of offences, timely detection and elimination of causes…
In the article, the author describes some comments on the objective signs of the crime of violation of customs legislation. Also, according to the author’s note, in today’s developed market economy and globalization…
This article highlights the recommendations of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development in the prevention of corruption in public procurement, and examples from the best practices of some OECD member…
Logical, systematic, and comparative legal methods of research were used in this article. In particular, first of all, the development of legal norms related to mitigating circumstances was described, as well as the…
This article provides a scientific analysis of the concepts of electronic or digital evidence. In particular, issues related to the legal and technical characteristics of digital evidence, their collection, storage…