The institution of diversion of juveniles from the criminal justice system is reflected in various international legal documents on the protection of child rights. This is a very significant and at the same time, according to critics, a rather controversial international standard. Thanks to the ongoing disputes between supporters and opponents of the institute and the constant work on mistakes, it has been developed in many countries. In order to get a full and objective idea of it, the article examines the reasons for its occurrence, stages of formation, prospects for the development of theory and practice. It is very important that at the time and throughout its existence, diversion measures faced strong resistance, but as a result, supporters of measures to divert from the formal justice system only grew in time and their positions were strengthened in science and practice. Research and years of meta-analyzes prove that they are more effective than formal criminal justice procedures. Research and years of meta-analyzes prove that they are more effective than formal criminal justice procedures. At the same time, it must be recognized that the results of these studies also show that diversion measures are not a panacea in themselves, but many times more effective than the official and formal process of criminal investigation and prosecution. In this regard, the article provides a review of foreign literature and the national law enforcement experience of the countries of the United States, England, Germany, and Japan. Its purpose is to obtain as much evidence of good practice as possible to ensure the best interests of a child in criminal proceedings, as well as to assess and avoid the risks of the negative experience of countries in implementating international legal instruments. In addition, it provides an overview of concepts and research findings on the diversion of juveniles from the criminal justice system, which also creates the basis for a smooth and competent implementation of these measures based on evidence-based findings.
| Mualliflar | Prosecutor’s Office of the Bukhara Region, Azizbek Tashev |
|---|---|
| Jurnal | Юридик фанлар ахборотномаси – Вестник юридических наук – Review of law sciences |
| Nashr sanasi | 2021-11-24 |
| Jild | 5 |
| Son | 2 |
| Betlar | 105-112 |
| Til | en |
| DOI | 10.51788/tsul.rols.2021.5.2./cdzb8703 |
DOI: 10.51788/tsul.rols.2021.5.2./cdzb8703 · Maqolaning asl sahifasi · PDF
The article is devoted to a comparative analysis of crime control systems in the field of trafficking in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances at the international level. This article discusses the problems of…
The article deals with the procedural issues regarding the initiation of criminal cases of a private prosecution on the example of domestic violence against women (victims). The problems of evidence in the criminal…
The article is devoted to the problems of the current legislation and law enforcement practice on the implementation of voluntary medical insurance contracts. Therefore, basic normative legal acts, regulating the…
Ensuring the right of citizens to favorable natural environment depends, first of all, on compliance with environmental standards in usage of land, water, underground and other natural resources, as well as following…
The article describes the medical and legal aspects of compulsory health insurance, the international legal framework, its emergence and development in different countries, the guaranteed and widespread use of medical…
The article discusses the key problems of improving corporate governance, especially the formation of profits in Uzbekistan in accordance with the provisions (standards) of accounting and corporate governance. In this…
This article contains the results of the study of the institute of suspended sentence, the dynamics of its socio-legal significance, the bases of application, the existing judicial practice and the definition in the…
This article deals with the themes of the execution of foreign arbitral awards in the Republic of Uzbekistan in the framework of the United Nations Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral…
This article focuses on the issues of international cooperation of prosecutors’ offices on provision of legal assistance in criminal matters. Besides, the article is dedicated to the matters concerning the cooperation…
Based on the scientific views and opinions of forensic scientists, the article analyzes the approaches to defining the goals and objectives of forensic support of the scene. Moreover, the article scientifically…
Юридик фанлар ахборотномаси – Вестник юридических наук – Review of law sciences — barcha maqolalar